"The arc of the moral universe is long, but it bends toward justice."
– Martin Luther King Jr.
History, in all its complexity, is not merely a sequence of events, but a mirror in which nations glimpse their true character. Few mirrors are as unforgiving—or as illuminating—as the history of race in the United States and the United Kingdom. These two powers—bound by language, colonial legacies, and a shared Enlightenment heritage—have followed profoundly different timelines in confronting and reconciling with racial injustice.
If we consider education, politics, civil rights, slavery, and racial science, the contrasts become not just chronological but philosophical. In many dimensions, the United States has trailed the UK by 50 to 100 years, often weighed down by a deeper internalization of racial caste. But this is not merely a comparison of progress charts. It is a study in how ideas—about freedom, reason, and humanity—have been interpreted or ignored across time and space.
1. Slavery: A Mirror of National Soul
The British Empire and the United States both committed atrocities in the name of economic expansion. But their moral reckonings came at starkly different moments.
-
United Kingdom: In 1807, Britain abolished the transatlantic slave trade. By 1833, it legislated emancipation across its colonies. This came without a civil war, though it wasn’t purely altruistic. Compensation was paid to slave owners—not to the enslaved—and slavery’s legacy continued through economic inequality in colonies.
-
United States: Slavery was not peripheral—it was central. The U.S. waited until 1865 to abolish slavery, after a bloody Civil War that left 600,000 dead. The promise of emancipation was crushed by Jim Crow laws, racial terror, and a segregated society. While Britain quietly distanced itself from slavery, the U.S. had to be torn apart to let go.
Enlightenment contrast: British abolition was driven, in part, by religious reformers and Enlightenment thinkers like William Wilberforce. In America, Enlightenment ideals of liberty coexisted with brutal enslavement for nearly a century longer. Jefferson owned slaves while writing that "all men are created equal."
2. Education: Gateways to Personhood
In Enlightenment thought, education is the great equalizer. But access to learning has always been a gatekeeping tool of white supremacy.
-
UK: Alexander Crummell, a Black American, graduated from Cambridge in 1853, before slavery even ended in the U.S. Over the next century, individuals of African and South Asian descent found access to British higher education, albeit with many barriers.
-
USA: The first African-American PhD holder, Edward Bouchet (Yale, 1876), was forced into segregated teaching because white institutions wouldn’t hire him. Desegregation of universities began only after Brown v. Board (1954) and faced violent resistance for decades.
Today, the UK still struggles with elitism and underrepresentation, especially at Oxbridge. But compared to the American system, which was deeply segregated until the 1970s, Britain’s doors opened earlier—if only slightly.
Enlightenment irony: The same Enlightenment that celebrated reason as universal often deemed Black and Indigenous minds as exceptions to that universality. The UK backed away from this contradiction earlier than the U.S., which doubled down on racial “science” to justify exclusion.
3. Political Power: From Subjects to Citizens
Political enfranchisement is the ultimate test of inclusion. And again, the timelines diverge.
-
UK:
-
Dadabhai Naoroji, of Indian descent, was elected to Parliament in 1892, despite colonial racism.
-
Paul Boateng, the son of a Ghanaian immigrant, became the UK’s first Black cabinet minister in 2002.
-
In 2022, the UK appointed Rishi Sunak, a Hindu of Indian heritage, as Prime Minister. A symbolic moment in a monarchy that once ruled over India.
-
-
USA:
-
Hiram Revels, the first Black U.S. Senator, was elected in 1870, but his successors were barred during Jim Crow.
-
Voting rights were violently suppressed until the 1965 Voting Rights Act.
-
Barack Obama’s election in 2008 was a monumental moment—but it unleashed a wave of white backlash still unfolding today.
-
Structural difference: The UK’s colonial racial hierarchy was external—projected onto colonies. The U.S. internalized its racial hierarchy, embedding it in every law, institution, and public square. The cost of challenging that system was—and remains—higher.
4. Eugenics and Racial Science: The Corruption of Reason
Enlightenment produced both human rights and pseudoscience. Nowhere was that duality clearer than in the eugenics movement.
-
UK: Francis Galton, cousin of Darwin, coined "eugenics" in the late 19th century. But while elites flirted with racial improvement theories, Britain never institutionalized eugenics as law.
-
USA: The U.S. took eugenics to terrifying heights.
-
Dozens of states passed sterilization laws, targeting the “unfit”—often Black, poor, or Indigenous women.
-
The Supreme Court upheld eugenics in Buck v. Bell (1927), allowing forced sterilization.
-
American eugenicists were cited as inspiration by Nazi Germany.
-
Moral paradox: The land that celebrated liberty and individual rights became a laboratory for racial control—long after the UK had moved toward a more inclusive, if still imperfect, understanding of equality.
5. Civil Rights and Anti-Racism: The Long March
-
UK:
-
The Race Relations Act (1965) outlawed public discrimination.
-
Expanded in 1968 and 1976, it laid the foundation for today’s Equality Act.
-
Britain had its own struggles—ranging from police racism to colonial migration—but never had to dismantle an entire apartheid-like legal system.
-
-
USA:
-
The Civil Rights Act (1964) and Voting Rights Act (1965) came only after sustained national protest and violence.
-
Black Americans were arrested, beaten, and killed simply for demanding access to basic rights.
-
Even now, voter suppression laws, gerrymandering, and police brutality continue to erode these gains.
-
Legacy: Britain legislated ahead of the curve; America legislated in response to crisis. This reveals a deeper resistance within the U.S. to letting go of racial hierarchy—despite its Enlightenment pretensions.
A Broader Enlightenment: Beyond the West
While we invoke Enlightenment ideals, it's important to acknowledge that the Enlightenment was not the exclusive domain of Europe. African, Indigenous, and Asian societies had their own rich intellectual traditions.
-
Indian thinkers like Rammohan Roy and Tagore questioned colonial modernity while embracing universalism.
-
African philosophers like Anton Wilhelm Amo (educated in Germany in the 1700s) challenged notions of racial inferiority even before modern anthropology existed.
-
Indigenous resistance to colonization was rooted not in anti-modernity, but in alternative models of liberty, ecology, and kinship.
True enlightenment is global. It is not when one nation abolishes slavery or elects a Black leader, but when the humanity of all peoples is no longer conditional.
Conclusion: Not Just Timelines, But Philosophies
The United Kingdom, despite its colonial arrogance and racial blind spots, moved faster in confronting institutional racism. Perhaps it was the externalization of its racialized power—onto colonies rather than internal populations—that allowed reforms to occur without a war. Perhaps it was simply a matter of fewer economic and political investments in racial caste at home.
The United States, by contrast, nurtured race as a domestic institution—from slavery to segregation to surveillance. Its racial reckoning has been bloody, delayed, and incomplete. The “American Dream” was built on exclusion, and the Enlightenment ideals it espoused were compromised by its own architecture.
And yet, in both countries, progress has always been forged by those on the margins—freedom fighters, abolitionists, artists, immigrants, philosophers—who refused to accept the status quo.
Today, as movements like Black Lives Matter, Windrush justice campaigns, and decolonization of curricula sweep both nations, the dream of a true Enlightenment—rooted in shared humanity, not racial hierarchy—feels, once again, possible.
Suggested Readings:
-
Black and British: A Forgotten History by David Olusoga
-
The Half Has Never Been Told by Edward Baptist
-
The Origins of the Urban Crisis by Thomas Sugrue
-
The Racial Contract by Charles Mills
-
Decolonizing the Mind by Ngũgĩ wa Thiong’o
No comments:
Post a Comment