Imagine two geese on a pond. One goose (call it Goose A) finds a fact — solid, verifiable, breadcrumb-certified. It holds the fact out to the other goose (Goose B).
Goose B flaps, scoffs, calls it “fake bread,” and honks louder. Not because Goose B hates truth — but because it feels exposed, threatened, wrong.
In some ponds, being wrong is worse than being dishonest.
1. Why Facts Can Backfire
Goose A thought facts would suffice. But our brains aren’t spreadsheets. They’re nests: messy, layered, emotional.
When you throw a fact into the wrong nest, it doesn’t settle in — it catches fire.
This is the heart of motivated reasoning: Goose B doesn’t assess information evenly. They defend what makes them feel safe, not what’s true.
Because if that nest of beliefs crumbles, the goose risks more than error — it risks its flock, its identity.
2. Belief = Identity
Some beliefs are mere facts. Others become armour. If you question them, it feels like plucking feathers off your wings.
Goose B doesn’t reject the data because it’s objectively wrong. It rejects it because if it’s right, everything else shifts: friends, family, the entire pond.
Changing your mind can feel like losing your flock.
3. Shame, Pride, and the Backfire Loop
Goose B isn’t evil. It’s scared. Admitting “I was wrong” isn’t simply tough — it hurts. Shame is a loud honk that drowns out reflection.
It’s easier to double-down than feel your wings droop.
So Goose B stays convinced — not because the fact is wrong, but because the world being safe matters more.
4. Echo Chambers & Cult-Ponds
Some geese live in info-bubbles. Every honk echoes what they already believe. A crumb that doesn’t fit? Propaganda.
“They’re hiding the truth. That’s why you’re showing me this politics. Fact-check my favorite goose and suddenly you’re the problem.”
Here allegiance and fear outweigh facts. And the algorithm? It sees what angers Goose B, serves more of it, spicier, louder. Because an outraged goose is an engaged goose — and engagement drives the line up.
Now Goose B isn’t only stuck — it’s being fed the same fear on purpose by a machine that doesn’t care who gets hurt.
5. What Actually Changes Minds?
Facts help. But only when there’s room to hear them. Minds start to open when:
-
Goose B feels safe enough to be wrong.
-
There’s trust, not trap-setting.
-
Questions are asked rather than judgments made.
-
Stories are told, relationships matter, real conversations happen.
-
Gentle curiosity replaces loud honks.
Final Goose Wisdom
Goose A learned: you can’t honk Goose B into seeing clearly. You can only show what it looks like to change your own mind — and survive it.
Because some geese never leave their bubbles. They’ll honk, subscribe, point out hypocrisy — but they might never actually see the breadcrumb you showed.
Broader context
This little metaphor speaks to something much larger: how in our digital age, facts alone don’t win hearts or minds. The ponds we live in — our social networks, our tribes, our news-feeds — shape how we receive truth.
Efforts to “correct” people often trigger defensive honks, not introspection. What shifts things is humility, patience, friendship, trust — the slow work of relationships.
If we want to change a mind, we might first need to change the pond.
Here’s the video that inspired this post. (Click and watch the “goose explains why facts don’t change minds” metaphor in action.)
No comments:
Post a Comment